• About
  • Contact
Friday, June 6, 2025
Catholic Sabah
  • News
    • All
    • Asia
    • Focus
    • Local
    • Nation
    • Vatican
    • World
    Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

    Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

    亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

    亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

    歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路	 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

    歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

    2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

    2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

    Ben&Ben named ‘Alay Kapwa’ mission ambassadors

    Ben&Ben named ‘Alay Kapwa’ mission ambassadors

    Pope Leo XIV meets Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors

    Pope Leo XIV meets Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors

    Pope: Secretariat of State a ‘hub of coordination’ with Church worldwide

    Pope: Secretariat of State a ‘hub of coordination’ with Church worldwide

    Lebih 70,000 peziarah dijangka mengambil bahagian dalam Jubli Pergerakan

    Lebih 70,000 peziarah dijangka mengambil bahagian dalam Jubli Pergerakan

    Thousands gather for declaration of India’s first Eucharist miracle

    Thousands gather for declaration of India’s first Eucharist miracle

  • Opinion
    • All
    • Im on my Way
    • Kanou Monuhid Lahan Koposizon
    • Making A Difference
    • Mantad Di Katekis Peter
    • Reflection: Straight Talking
    Challenges of teaching theology in lived experiences

    Challenges of teaching theology in lived experiences

    Myth and history

    Myth and history

    Did Teresa of Avila inspire Descartes’ ‘I think, therefore I am’?

    Did Teresa of Avila inspire Descartes’ ‘I think, therefore I am’?

    Are conclaves really secret?

    Are conclaves really secret?

    Kartini Day and gender justice in Indonesian Catholicism

    Kartini Day and gender justice in Indonesian Catholicism

    What Catholic Sabah stands for

    Cohabitation – trial run for marriage?

    The meaning of Easter

    The meaning of Easter

    How reflection and brain exercises shape my spirituality

    How reflection and brain exercises shape my spirituality

  • Feature
    Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

    Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

    South Korean Catholic convert finds strength in Legion of Mary

    South Korean Catholic convert finds strength in Legion of Mary

    Slogan “Bahasa Jiwa Bangsa” harus dipupuk hingga ke generasi seterusnya

    Slogan “Bahasa Jiwa Bangsa” harus dipupuk hingga ke generasi seterusnya

    Bahasa ibunda adalah warisan dalam kehidupan

    Bahasa ibunda adalah warisan dalam kehidupan

    Remembering Francis, a Pope who led the Church to the peripheries

    Remembering Francis, a Pope who led the Church to the peripheries

    A Filipina nanny’s turbulent journey to Cambodia tells a bigger story

    A Filipina nanny’s turbulent journey to Cambodia tells a bigger story

    Personal sharing of 25 years in the priesthood

    Personal sharing of 25 years in the priesthood

    Pope Leo XIV and the soul of the machine

    Pope Leo XIV and the soul of the machine

  • Statements
    World Day of Social Communications 2025 message by Pope Francis

    World Day of Social Communications 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Banns of Sacerdotal Ordination

    Banns of Sacerdotal Ordination

    Perutusan daripada Presiden Persidangan Uskup-Uskup Katolik Malaysia sempena Hari Malaysia

    Pastoral Letter on Earthquake in Myanmar and Regional Solidarity Appeal

    Chancery Notice

    Chancery Notice

    FABC Pastoral Letter to the local churches in Asia

    FABC Pastoral Letter to the local churches in Asia

    Commotion in Church: Press statement from Archbishop Simon Poh

    Commotion in Church: Press statement from Archbishop Simon Poh

    Lent 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Lent 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Pastoral Statement for dispensation from fasting  during Chinese New Year 2025

    Pastoral Statement for dispensation from fasting during Chinese New Year 2025

  • Chinese
  • Bahasa Melayu
  • Kadazan Dusun
  • JUBILEE 2025
  • About
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Asia
    • Focus
    • Local
    • Nation
    • Vatican
    • World
    Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

    Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

    亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

    亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

    歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路	 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

    歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

    2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

    2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

    Ben&Ben named ‘Alay Kapwa’ mission ambassadors

    Ben&Ben named ‘Alay Kapwa’ mission ambassadors

    Pope Leo XIV meets Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors

    Pope Leo XIV meets Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors

    Pope: Secretariat of State a ‘hub of coordination’ with Church worldwide

    Pope: Secretariat of State a ‘hub of coordination’ with Church worldwide

    Lebih 70,000 peziarah dijangka mengambil bahagian dalam Jubli Pergerakan

    Lebih 70,000 peziarah dijangka mengambil bahagian dalam Jubli Pergerakan

    Thousands gather for declaration of India’s first Eucharist miracle

    Thousands gather for declaration of India’s first Eucharist miracle

  • Opinion
    • All
    • Im on my Way
    • Kanou Monuhid Lahan Koposizon
    • Making A Difference
    • Mantad Di Katekis Peter
    • Reflection: Straight Talking
    Challenges of teaching theology in lived experiences

    Challenges of teaching theology in lived experiences

    Myth and history

    Myth and history

    Did Teresa of Avila inspire Descartes’ ‘I think, therefore I am’?

    Did Teresa of Avila inspire Descartes’ ‘I think, therefore I am’?

    Are conclaves really secret?

    Are conclaves really secret?

    Kartini Day and gender justice in Indonesian Catholicism

    Kartini Day and gender justice in Indonesian Catholicism

    What Catholic Sabah stands for

    Cohabitation – trial run for marriage?

    The meaning of Easter

    The meaning of Easter

    How reflection and brain exercises shape my spirituality

    How reflection and brain exercises shape my spirituality

  • Feature
    Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

    Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

    South Korean Catholic convert finds strength in Legion of Mary

    South Korean Catholic convert finds strength in Legion of Mary

    Slogan “Bahasa Jiwa Bangsa” harus dipupuk hingga ke generasi seterusnya

    Slogan “Bahasa Jiwa Bangsa” harus dipupuk hingga ke generasi seterusnya

    Bahasa ibunda adalah warisan dalam kehidupan

    Bahasa ibunda adalah warisan dalam kehidupan

    Remembering Francis, a Pope who led the Church to the peripheries

    Remembering Francis, a Pope who led the Church to the peripheries

    A Filipina nanny’s turbulent journey to Cambodia tells a bigger story

    A Filipina nanny’s turbulent journey to Cambodia tells a bigger story

    Personal sharing of 25 years in the priesthood

    Personal sharing of 25 years in the priesthood

    Pope Leo XIV and the soul of the machine

    Pope Leo XIV and the soul of the machine

  • Statements
    World Day of Social Communications 2025 message by Pope Francis

    World Day of Social Communications 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Banns of Sacerdotal Ordination

    Banns of Sacerdotal Ordination

    Perutusan daripada Presiden Persidangan Uskup-Uskup Katolik Malaysia sempena Hari Malaysia

    Pastoral Letter on Earthquake in Myanmar and Regional Solidarity Appeal

    Chancery Notice

    Chancery Notice

    FABC Pastoral Letter to the local churches in Asia

    FABC Pastoral Letter to the local churches in Asia

    Commotion in Church: Press statement from Archbishop Simon Poh

    Commotion in Church: Press statement from Archbishop Simon Poh

    Lent 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Lent 2025 message by Pope Francis

    Pastoral Statement for dispensation from fasting  during Chinese New Year 2025

    Pastoral Statement for dispensation from fasting during Chinese New Year 2025

  • Chinese
  • Bahasa Melayu
  • Kadazan Dusun
  • JUBILEE 2025
  • About
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
Catholic Sabah
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Challenges of teaching theology in lived experiences

The purpose of theologizing is to foster a ‘thinking faith’ and cultivate more committed disciples of Jesus

June 3, 2025
in Opinion
We need to give our religious assent to God’s Word in order to deepen our communion in faith. However, that does not mean we should refrain from asking questions or raising concerns about the Church’s doctrine and life (Photo: La Civilta Cattolica)

By Ruben C Mendoza

Unlike other Christian traditions, the Roman Catholic Church has official teachings to which Catholics are expected to give their assent of faith (see Lumen Gentium 25). Dissent from any of those teachings is frowned upon to the extent that the catholicity of the dissenter is questioned.

However, many Catholics do not find satisfactory answers in the Church’s magisterial teachings regarding their existential questions.

These teachings appear inadequate and unresponsive to the sensibilities of many, particularly the LGBTQIA+ community, who feel that their experiences are overlooked and devalued by those who uphold the Church’s heteronormative doctrines. They cannot, in good conscience, give their assent to what they perceive as unfair and discriminatory teachings.

I was once in a forum with other theologians from two universities in Manila. One of them shared that he followed the see-judge-act methodology in his classes. He went on to explain that during the “seeing” part, he listened to the students’ understandings of the Church’s teachings.

In many instances, they had questions about the Church’s sexual ethics, including its teachings on homosexuality. According to him, his students were given the chance to articulate their concerns.

Then, in the “judging” part, he explained the Church’s teachings and “corrected” his students’ misunderstandings about the doctrines in question. In this way, he honestly believed that he seriously considered the context of his students and responded to them.

While this process may address specific concerns of students, as described by the teacher, there seems to be a misunderstanding of the significance of the students’ contexts and what the Christian faith conveys about them.

The teacher was evidently unaware of the dialectical relationship between context, with all its complexities, and the Word of God. He viewed the “judging” aspect as a one-way street in which the Word is merely applied to the context, assuming that the Church’s interpretation of that Word responds to their concerns.

He seemed to overlook that while the Church’s doctrines might be clear and meaningful to him, this does not imply that his explanation, originating from his context and rooted in the magisterium’s interpretation of God’s revelation, will be clear and meaningful to the students. He also appeared to believe that with the right explanation, students would have a light bulb moment.

If we are honest, many theology students in Catholic colleges and universities in the Philippines have questions about the Christian faith. Many feel alienated from the Church, and some have ceased participating in its liturgy.

Still others reject what they consider the Church’s indoctrination efforts, similar to the ideological programs of other interest groups. As one of my students said, “Religion is hypocritical,” because he finds a dissonance between the Church’s teaching about the centrality of love and the way it treats marginalized groups or sectors within the Church.

If we are to do and teach theology inductively, Catholic theologians must be humble enough to admit what they don’t know, that the teachings of the Church do not answer all of life’s questions, and that the last word of theology still has to be written.

They also need to remember that the teachings of the Church are not the last word on those topics, but instead starting points for contemporary discussion and can be subjected to criticisms that lead to their development.

It is also essential to consider that the concerns articulated by students should take precedence over what theologians believe they ought to know. Orthodoxy is important, but it should not prevent us from further exploring its meanings and even expressing them in ways that are sensitive to various contexts, lest those same teachings become tools for discrimination and oppression.

In my experience, students are turned off by teachers who, while rightly being true to their beliefs, do not consider other perspectives and are closed to any theological dialogue.

While we need to help our students know, understand, and appreciate the Catholic faith, the purpose of theologizing is to foster a ‘thinking faith’ and cultivate more committed disciples of Jesus in today’s world.

It is crucial that we provide students with the space to question established traditions. In doing so, we need to remind them to be open and not to stop looking for answers. It may happen that we won’t have answers to our students’ questions and that we will find it difficult to affirm magisterial teachings in light of the students’ objections.

When we are placed in that corner, let us embark on a shared journey with them and seek answers to those questions together. Like our students, we are called and challenged to deepen our understanding of God’s Word and, if necessary, unlearn our previous misunderstandings of that same Word.

We need to give our religious assent to God’s Word in order to deepen our communion in faith.

However, that does not mean we should refrain from asking questions or raising concerns about the Church’s doctrine and life.

We must remember that divine revelation is not only a past occurrence, for the Christian God continues to reveal Godself to us in our everyday experiences, always inviting us to be God’s friends. Each of us is called to discern God’s presence as this God reveals Godself to us.

Engaging in and teaching theology will provide a map that helps us navigate life as we journey with others toward the Kingdom. – UCA News

 

*The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official editorial position of UCA News.

Previous Post

Communicating hope in a time of crisis: Reflection from the Holy Land

Next Post

Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

Related Posts

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025
Bahasa Melayu

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

June 6, 2025
亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行
Chinese

亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

June 6, 2025
歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路	 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向
Chinese

歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

June 6, 2025
Next Post
Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

Council of Constantinople reaffirms Christ’s divinity and clarifies the Trinity

Recent News

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

June 6, 2025
亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

June 6, 2025
歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路	 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

June 6, 2025
2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

June 6, 2025
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Minor reshuffle and new appointment of priests

Minor reshuffle and new appointment of priests

July 15, 2024
Enggan punya anak, antara sebab perpisahan suami-isteri

Enggan punya anak, antara sebab perpisahan suami-isteri

May 20, 2025
Minor transfer of priests

Minor transfer of priests

November 11, 2023
Tender Notice St Catherine of Laboure Church, Putatan

Tender Notice St Catherine of Laboure Church, Putatan

April 29, 2025
The Church wants to be more the ‘inn’ of the Good Samaritan for the sick

The Church wants to be more the ‘inn’ of the Good Samaritan for the sick

Parishioners are invited to help form prophetic and servant priests

Parishioners are invited to help form prophetic and servant priests

Archdiocesan Notice on SSPX

Archdiocesan Notice on SSPX

April 28 2020

April 28 2020

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

June 6, 2025
亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

June 6, 2025
歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路	 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

June 6, 2025
2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

June 6, 2025
Catholic Sabah

Catholic Sabah is a media organization based in Sabah Malaysia. We bring you the latest Catholic news right to your doorstep!

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Asia
  • Bahasa Melayu
  • Borneo: Ordinary Person, Extraordinary Faith
  • Chinese
  • Feature
  • Focus
  • Im on my Way
  • JUBILEE 2025
  • Kadazan Dusun
  • Kanou Monuhid Lahan Koposizon
  • Local
  • Making A Difference
  • Mantad Di Katekis Peter
  • Nation
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Readings
  • Reflection: Straight Talking
  • Statements
  • Vatican
  • World

Recent Additions

Perhimpunan Pastoral Wilayah Sabah 2025

亞庇總教區大眾傳播委員會反省日在聖神內同行

歷史性的沙巴區域牧民大會為2026年馬來西亞牧靈大會鋪路 : 在聖神内,彼此聆听,一起辨認本地教會牧民動向

2025年第九屆馬來西亞加爾默羅在俗會全國大會:耶穌,我們的希望

Ben&Ben named ‘Alay Kapwa’ mission ambassadors

Pope Leo XIV meets Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors

  • About
  • Contact

© 2024 Catholic Sabah - Powered by KK Top Web.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Statements
  • Chinese
  • Bahasa Melayu
  • Kadazan Dusun
  • JUBILEE 2025
  • About
  • Donate

© 2024 Catholic Sabah - Powered by KK Top Web.